Best Famous Five Sequels...and the worst

[Moonraker]

It's interesting to see your list, Bertie. I too would put Five Have a Mystery to Solve at the bottom of the pile as I find it flat and uninspiring, even if the (understandable) continuity errors are disregarded.

You may enjoy looking at the following thread, where a number of people have listed the Famous Five books in order of preference:

Thanks of reminding us about this thread, Anita. I often wonder why a topic suddenly grinds to a halt.

[John Pickup]

I cannot see where Anita has reminded us of this thread. All I can see is timv's post in 2015 followed by Nigel's post this morning.

[Bertie]

I cannot see where Anita has reminded us of this thread. All I can see is timv's post in 2015 followed by Nigel's post this morning.

It was on the 'Your Top 3 Famous Five books' thread. I listed all 21 in order (of my preferences), and Anita supplied a link to this old thread.

Here's my ordering of the Famous Five books from the other thread...

Five Go To Smugglers Top
Five Get Into Trouble
Five Run Away Together
Five On A Treasure Island
Five Go Off To Camp
Five Go Adventuring Again
Five On Kirrin Island Again
Five Fall Into Adventure
Five Go Off In A Caravan
Five Go To Mystery Moor
Five Go Down To The Sea
Five Have A Wonderful Time
Five On A Hike Together
Five Go To Billycock Hill
Five On Finniston Farm
Five On a Secret Trail
Five Have Plenty Of Fun
Five Go To Demons Rocks
Five Get Into A Fix
Five Are Together Again
Five Have A Mystery To Solve

[Moonraker]

I cannot see where Anita has reminded us of this thread. All I can see is timv's post in 2015 followed by Nigel's post this morning.

Sorry, John. I should have quoted Anita's post.

It's interesting to see your list, Bertie. I too would put Five Have a Mystery to Solve at the bottom of the pile as I find it flat and uninspiring, even if the (understandable) continuity errors are disregarded.

You may enjoy looking at the following thread, where a number of people have listed the Famous Five books in order of preference:

viewtopic.php?f=4&t=5672&hilit=order

[John Pickup]

Thanks, Nigel. That clears it up.