Moonraker wrote:the NT are quite happy to say that Corfe Castle has a connection with Kirrin Island/Castle - yet totally ignores the fact that Brownsea was Whispering Island. No mention of this from the boatman in his commentary, either.
I have just read Enid's Special Note in Five Have a Mystery to Solve, and Brownsea Island isn't mentioned by name -
Enid Blyton wrote: only that the island is real, and lies in the great harbour, still full of whispering trees.
There are several islands in Poole Harbour, do we know for sure that Brownsea is the island in question?
Mrs Mary Bonham-Christie bought Brownsea Island in 1927. She quickly banished all residents from the island & banned any visitors, too. She briefly had two Men patrolling the island to ward off would-be visitors. She was known throughout the Isle of Purbeck & had a fierce reputation as an hard nosed individual. These facts are mirrored to some degree in "have a Mystery to solve". Enid, who was a regular visitor to Purbeck, would've undoubtedly had heard of Mrs Bonham-Christie & her 'out of bounds' island!
I seem to recollect seeing you on one of your guided tours on Brownsea, Viv. Can't decide whether I was on the tour or just observing for a few moments. Think It was the latter. My memory is terrible at the moment!